DeChelli's Italian Cafe
Nestled in the heart of New Middletown, DeChelli's Italian Cafe captures the essence of Italian cuisine with an inviting warmth and authenticity. Located at 11092 Main St, New Middletown, OH 44442, this Italian gem serves up hearty flavors and classic dishes that keep locals and visitors coming back for more. Known for its warm ambiance and handcrafted dishes, DeChelli’s offers more than just a meal—it’s an experience that transports you to Italy with each bite.
Traditional Italian Flavors with a Twist at DeChelli's Italian Cafe
One of the standout features of DeChelli's Italian Cafe is its dedication to authentic Italian flavors, fused with a touch of creative flair. DeChelli’s menu is a delightful journey through Italy’s culinary landscape, featuring everything from rustic pasta dishes to thin-crust pizzas that are as visually appealing as they are delicious. Each dish is meticulously crafted, paying homage to traditional Italian cooking methods.
At the heart of DeChelli's menu, you’ll find popular Italian dishes such as spaghetti alla carbonara and margherita pizza, which showcase the cafe's commitment to quality ingredients. Every ingredient is chosen for freshness and flavor, from the tomatoes and basil to the parmesan cheese. For those looking to explore beyond the classics, DeChelli's offers inventive dishes that incorporate modern twists on Italian traditions, blending bold flavors in new, exciting ways.
Warm, Inviting Atmosphere at DeChelli's Italian Cafe
Stepping into DeChelli’s Italian Cafe feels like entering a cozy trattoria in a quaint Italian village. The cafe’s design is intentionally welcoming, with warm lighting and rustic decor that evoke the essence of Italy’s charm. This thoughtfully curated atmosphere encourages guests to slow down and enjoy their dining experience fully, whether for a family meal or an intimate dinner for two. The casual yet elegant decor invites patrons to relax, savoring not just the food but the ambiance and camaraderie of a meal shared.
The cafe’s staff contributes significantly to the experience at DeChelli’s. Known for their friendliness and knowledge of the menu, they can recommend dishes, suggest wine pairings, and provide insights into the Italian culinary traditions behind the cafe’s offerings. The seamless blend of attentive service and inviting decor make DeChelli's a memorable destination for Italian cuisine lovers.
Fresh, Locally-Sourced Ingredients That Set DeChelli's Apart
DeChelli’s Italian Cafe places a strong emphasis on the quality and freshness of its ingredients. Every meal served here is made from scratch, with ingredients sourced locally whenever possible. This dedication to using local produce not only supports the community but also enhances the flavor and nutritional value of the dishes. Fresh ingredients, such as tomatoes for the signature marinara sauce and herbs for various dishes, bring out the vibrant, authentic flavors that Italian cuisine is known for.
This commitment to quality extends to DeChelli’s house-made pasta, sauces, and even desserts. With each dish prepared fresh, guests can be assured that they’re receiving a meal made with the utmost care and attention to detail. The focus on freshness and flavor is central to the cafe’s identity and sets it apart from other Italian eateries in the area.
DeChelli’s Italian Cafe: A Destination for Food Lovers and Families Alike
Whether you're a solo diner, a couple, or part of a family group, DeChelli's Italian Cafe offers a welcoming environment for everyone. The menu has been thoughtfully curated to include a range of options to satisfy diverse tastes and dietary preferences. For families with children, DeChelli’s offers kid-friendly meals that make the dining experience enjoyable for all ages. Couples can enjoy a romantic Italian dinner with a selection of wines that perfectly complement the dishes on offer.
Beyond dining in, DeChelli’s Italian Cafe also offers convenient takeaway options for those who want to enjoy a taste of Italy from the comfort of home. The cafe’s commitment to catering to a wide range of patrons ensures that everyone, from locals to visitors, finds something they love at DeChelli’s.
Reviews
We ordered take-out. The food was absolutely delicious...from the wedding soup, meatball Stromboli to the Kevin's fish Italiano. We will definitely be going back.
We are in town for a softball tournament We stopped to eat between games and it was so good and big portions I got the Parmesan crusted chicken with penne My husband got the hot sausage patty and my 12 yo got fried provolone and fries We split the strawberry shortcake Everything was amazing They were so personal as well we were the only ones there and they put on the music we liked Definitely will be back
Saw an ad in the newspaper for this place. Never been here before, but I thought I would give it a try. It was Friday, so I thought I'd order a fish dinner. You can get broiled, fried panko coated, or beer battered. They also offer your choice of a regular fish dinner, a dinner with an extra large piece of fish, or all you can eat. I chose the panko coated extra large fish. It comes with cole slaw and bread and butter, and your choice of side: either French fries, macaroni and cheese, mashed potatoes, or a baked potato. I selected mashed potatoes. They scored big points with me as the mashed potatoes are REAL potatoes and not instant. The fish was outstanding... perhaps the best in the Mahoning Valley. It wasn't greasy. It was a generous size piece of fish, served hot and delicious. My wife who is not a fan of fried fish at all couldn't stop from taking "samples" from my plate. It's that good! The restaurant is a little out of the way, but it's worth the drive. I'm going back soon to try some of their other menu items.
If DeChellis' was in the middle of a city, I'd give it three stars -- because it's quaint, clean, laid back, and reasonably inexpensive for the quality of the menu offerings and the execution of the recipes. But because of where it's located -- basically in the middle of almost completely rural nowhere, in a non-descript but well-maintained building (the purple awnings are a smart touch, because they're the only thing that stands out amid a slow river of grey cinder block and beige brick buildings that line the Rt 170 roadside) -- it gets four stars. Because it's a rare and happy find to stumble onto a place like this without any forethought. Go with reasonable expectations for what it is -- you'll be pleasantly surprised, and you'll leave happy. Would make a nice impromptu date for a new couple, or one that finds themselves in transit and hankering for a decent sit-down meal.
Been going here for years! The food is delicious, home style and big portions. The owners are great.